Subaru Outback vs Toyota Grand Highlander

Verdict: Subaru Outback vs Toyota Grand Highlander

The Toyota Grand Highlander demonstrates superior reliability compared to the Subaru Outback, with an average reliability score of 85/100 versus 74/100 for the Outback. The Grand Highlander has a lower owner complaint rate of 8.2 per 10,000 sold compared to the Outback's 26.1, and it has experienced fewer recalls, with 10 over three years compared to the Outback's 22 across nine years. While specific repair cost estimates for the Grand Highlander are unavailable, the Outback's estimated annual repair cost is $607. The key differentiators are the Grand Highlander's higher reliability score and significantly lower complaint rate, making it the more reliable choice in the midsize SUV segment.

Reliability problem analysis

The Subaru Outback shows a high number of complaints in the visibility/wiper and electrical system categories, with the electrical system issues notably resulting in eight crash-linked incidents. In contrast, the Toyota Grand Highlander has significantly fewer total complaints, with the highest being in the "unknown or other" and power train categories, and only one crash-linked complaint associated with air bags. The Outback's air bag system also presents a safety concern, with 15 crash-linked complaints, indicating a potential area of severity that the Grand Highlander does not exhibit. Overall, the Outback's problem profile suggests more frequent and severe issues across multiple components compared to the Grand Highlander.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize reliability and peace of mind, the Toyota Grand Highlander is your best bet. With a higher reliability score of 85/100 and fewer total recalls (10 compared to the Subaru's 22), it demonstrates a stronger track record. The Grand Highlander also has fewer owner complaints, at just 8.2 per 10,000 sold, suggesting a more satisfying ownership experience. Though specific repair costs and frequencies are not available, the lower incidence of issues like power train and electrical system problems makes it a solid choice for those seeking dependability.

On the other hand, if you are budget-conscious and can tolerate a slightly higher risk of issues, the Subaru Outback could be suitable. With an estimated annual repair cost of $607 and a repair frequency of 0.4 per year, it offers manageable running costs. However, be prepared for a higher likelihood of dealing with issues related to visibility and the electrical system, given its 12% risk of major repairs. Choose the Outback if you value cost savings and are comfortable with occasional maintenance needs.

Cost of ownership

The Subaru Outback's annual repair cost is $607, with an average of 0.4 repair visits per year and a 12% chance of encountering a major repair. This translates to roughly one repair visit every 2.5 years, with a moderate risk of significant issues, which could impact long-term ownership costs.

In contrast, the Toyota Grand Highlander's specific repair costs and frequency are unavailable, but Toyota's reputation for reliability often suggests lower maintenance expenses and fewer repair visits. For cost-conscious buyers, the Subaru Outback presents a clear picture of predictable expenses, while the Grand Highlander may offer better value if it aligns with Toyota's typical low maintenance profile.