Toyota Camry vs Subaru Legacy

Verdict: Toyota Camry vs Subaru Legacy

The Toyota Camry edges out the Subaru Legacy in reliability with a higher average score of 78/100 compared to 75/100. Despite having more recalls (35 vs. 19), the Camry exhibits significantly fewer owner complaints per 10,000 vehicles at 2.1, compared to the Legacy’s 21.2. Additionally, the Camry benefits from lower estimated annual repair costs at $388 versus the Legacy's $563. While both vehicles share some common issues, the Camry’s lower complaint rate and repair costs make it a more reliable choice.

Reliability problem analysis

The Toyota Camry exhibits a broader range of issues across its components, with notable concerns in the power train, air bags, and service brakes, which collectively account for a significant portion of complaints and are linked to crashes more frequently than other categories. The air bags issue stands out with 58 crash-linked complaints, suggesting a critical area of concern for safety. In contrast, the Subaru Legacy shows a concentrated problem profile, primarily with visibility and electrical system issues, which make up the bulk of its complaints. Although the Legacy has fewer total complaints, the vehicle speed control category is a noteworthy safety concern with a high proportion of crash-linked incidents relative to its total number.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize low running costs and fewer owner complaints, the Toyota Camry is a better choice. With an estimated annual repair cost of $388 and only 2.1 owner complaints per 10,000 sold, it offers a more affordable and smoother ownership experience. Although it has a slightly higher reliability score of 78/100 and a major repair risk of 11%, it has been subject to more recalls, totaling 35. However, its overall performance and lower repair costs make it appealing for budget-conscious buyers.

If you seek fewer recalls and can handle slightly higher running costs, consider the Subaru Legacy. With only 19 recalls and a reliability score of 75/100, it offers a reliable drive, despite the higher frequency of owner complaints at 21.2 per 10,000 sold. The annual repair cost is estimated at $563, with a major repair risk of 12%. Its appeal lies in fewer recalls, making it a suitable option if recalls are your primary concern.

Cost of ownership

Based on independent repair cost data, the Toyota Camry presents a lower annual repair cost of $388 compared to the Subaru Legacy's $563. This translates to a $175 savings per year, or $875 over five years. Both vehicles have a similar repair frequency of 0.3 visits per year, indicating reliability in terms of how often they need attention. However, the Camry has a slightly lower major repair risk at 11%, compared to the Legacy's 12%, suggesting a marginally better long-term reliability profile. For cost-conscious buyers, the Camry offers better value with lower annual expenses and reduced risk of significant repairs.