Nissan Ariya vs Subaru Solterra

Verdict: Nissan Ariya vs Subaru Solterra

The Nissan Ariya demonstrates superior reliability with an average score of 85/100 compared to the Subaru Solterra's score of 0/100. The Ariya also has a lower recall count, with four recalls over four years, while the Solterra has experienced six recalls in just three years. Although the Ariya has a higher owner complaint rate of 112.8 per 10,000 sold, its estimated annual repair cost is a reasonable $500, with identified issues primarily in the electrical system and power train. Overall, the Ariya's reliability metrics position it as a more dependable choice in the midsize SUV segment.

Reliability problem analysis

The Subaru Solterra has 43 total complaints, but lacks detailed problem data, making it difficult to pinpoint specific areas of concern. In contrast, the Nissan Ariya has 52 complaints, with a significant focus on the electrical system, accounting for half of its total issues. Additionally, the Ariya has notable issues in the power train category, including one complaint linked to a crash, which suggests a potential safety concern. While both models have similar total complaint numbers, the Ariya's detailed problem breakdown highlights more diverse and potentially severe issues.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize reliability and peace of mind, the Nissan Ariya is your best bet. With a reliability score of 85/100, it significantly outperforms the Subaru Solterra, which has a concerning score of 0/100. The Ariya's estimated annual repair cost is around $500, making it a relatively affordable choice for maintenance. Although it has four recalls and some owner complaints, these issues are well-documented, allowing you to make informed decisions.

On the other hand, if you are drawn to the Subaru brand, be prepared for potential challenges with the Solterra. Its zero reliability score and six recalls highlight significant concerns that might require attention. With 43 owner complaints and no detailed repair cost estimates available, this model might be best suited for those who are willing to take a risk for the potential of future improvements. Choose wisely based on your priorities and risk tolerance.

Cost of ownership

Subaru's Solterra lacks specific data on annual repair costs, repair frequency, and major repair risk, making it challenging to assess its long-term maintenance expenses. In contrast, independent repair cost data for the Nissan Ariya suggests an annual repair cost of $500. Over five years, this totals $2,500. Without clear data on the Solterra, potential owners may face uncertainty regarding unexpected repair expenses.

For cost-conscious buyers, the Nissan Ariya may present a more predictable financial commitment due to available industry estimates. The lack of detailed repair data for the Solterra could imply either a potential advantage or risk, depending on the actual maintenance needs that may emerge over time.