Toyota Camry vs Nissan Altima

Verdict: Toyota Camry vs Nissan Altima

The Toyota Camry edges out the Nissan Altima in overall reliability with an average reliability score of 88/100 versus the Altima's 83/100. Despite having more recalls over nine years (35 for the Camry versus 20 for the Altima), the Camry boasts a lower estimated annual repair cost at $388 compared to the Altima's $483. While the Altima has a slightly lower owner complaint rate of 1.6 per 10,000 sold compared to the Camry's 2.1, the Camry's lower repair costs and higher reliability score make it a more dependable choice for midsize sedan buyers.

Reliability problem analysis

The Toyota Camry exhibits a higher total number of complaints compared to the Nissan Altima, but both models share similar concerns regarding their power train and electrical systems. Notably, the Camry has a significant number of crash-linked complaints related to its air bags (58) and service brakes (23), highlighting potential safety issues. In contrast, the Altima's most reported problems are with the electrical system and unknown or other categories, with fewer overall crash-linked complaints, except in the air bags category where it also has a notable 18 crash-related complaints. Both vehicles show vulnerabilities in critical safety components, though the Camry's issues appear more pronounced in terms of crash-related incidents.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize low running costs and long-term reliability, the Toyota Camry is an excellent choice. With a higher reliability score of 88/100 and a lower estimated annual repair cost of $388, the Camry offers peace of mind over the years. Despite having more recalls (35), it maintains fewer owner complaints per 10,000 sold at 2.1, indicating a generally satisfied customer base. Its major repair risk stands at 11%, slightly better than the Altima, making it a dependable option for those who value consistency.

On the other hand, if you are concerned about the number of recalls and prefer a model with fewer of them, the Nissan Altima might appeal to you. It has 20 total recalls and a slightly lower owner complaint rate of 1.6 per 10,000 sold. However, the Altima comes with a higher estimated annual repair cost of $483 and a marginally higher major repair risk of 12%. Choose the Altima if you value fewer recalls and are comfortable with a bit higher maintenance costs.

Cost of ownership

Independent repair cost data indicates that the Toyota Camry is more economical for cost-conscious buyers. With an annual repair cost of $388, the Camry saves $95 each year compared to the Nissan Altima's $483, resulting in a $475 savings over five years. Both vehicles have a repair frequency of 0.3 visits per year, indicating similar reliability in terms of service visits. However, the Camry has a slightly lower major repair risk at 11%, compared to the Altima's 12%, suggesting a marginally lower likelihood of incurring significant repair expenses. Overall, the Camry offers better value in terms of maintenance and repair costs.