Nissan Altima vs Subaru Legacy

Verdict: Nissan Altima vs Subaru Legacy

The Nissan Altima edges out the Subaru Legacy in terms of reliability, with a higher average reliability score of 79/100 compared to the Legacy's 75/100. The Altima also boasts a significantly lower owner complaint rate of 1.6 per 10,000 sold versus the Legacy's 21.2, suggesting better overall owner satisfaction. While both vehicles have similar recall histories, the Altima presents a lower estimated annual repair cost at $483, compared to the Legacy's $563. These factors make the Altima a more reliable choice for midsize sedan buyers.

Reliability problem analysis

The Nissan Altima and Subaru Legacy exhibit distinct problem profiles in terms of reliability issues. The Altima shows a higher incidence of complaints in the electrical system, unknown or other, and service brakes categories, with notable crash-linked issues in the air bags (18) and service brakes (14). Conversely, the Subaru Legacy's most frequent problem lies in visibility/wiper complaints, although it has fewer crash-linked complaints overall, with vehicle speed control being the most significant at 7. While both models have electrical system concerns, the Altima's issues are more diverse and severe, particularly in safety-critical areas such as air bags and brakes.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize low running costs and a slightly higher reliability score, the Nissan Altima might be your best bet. With a reliability score of 79/100 and an estimated annual repair cost of $483, it is a more economical choice. The Altima also has fewer owner complaints per 10,000 sold at 1.6, suggesting a generally more satisfying ownership experience. However, keep in mind its top issues with the electrical system and service brakes.

On the other hand, if you are seeking a vehicle with fewer recalls and don't mind spending a bit more on maintenance, consider the Subaru Legacy. While its reliability score is slightly lower at 75/100, it has only 19 recalls compared to the Altima's 20. However, be prepared for higher owner complaints at 21.2 per 10,000 sold and an annual repair cost of $563. The Legacy is best for those who can overlook these factors in favor of its performance and handling.

Cost of ownership

Based on industry estimates, the Nissan Altima and Subaru Legacy both have a repair frequency of 0.3 visits per year and a 12% risk of major repairs, indicating similar reliability profiles. However, the Altima stands out with an annual repair cost of $483, which is $80 less than the Legacy's $563. Over a span of five years, this amounts to a $400 savings for Altima owners.

For cost-conscious buyers prioritizing lower maintenance expenses, the Altima offers better value while maintaining comparable repair frequency and major repair risk to the Legacy. The Altima's lower annual repair costs can provide financial relief without compromising on reliability.