Volkswagen Tiguan vs Mazda CX-5

Verdict: Volkswagen Tiguan vs Mazda CX-5

The Mazda CX-5 stands out as a more reliable choice compared to the Volkswagen Tiguan, with an impressive average reliability score of 93/100 versus the Tiguan's 68/100. The CX-5 also benefits from lower owner complaints at 5.6 per 10,000 sold, compared to the Tiguan's 9.3 per 10,000. Additionally, the CX-5 incurs lower estimated annual repair costs at $447, significantly less than the Tiguan's $730. With fewer recalls (11 over nine years versus the Tiguan's 35), the Mazda CX-5 clearly demonstrates superior reliability in the compact SUV segment.

Reliability problem analysis

The Mazda CX-5 and Volkswagen Tiguan both exhibit issues with their electrical systems and engines, with the CX-5 having more complaints related to the engine at 263 compared to the Tiguan's 128. Notably, the CX-5 has a higher number of crash-linked complaints in areas such as air bags and vehicle speed control, with 11 complaints each, suggesting potential safety concerns. Conversely, the Tiguan shows a significant number of complaints in the electrical system at 176, though with fewer crash-linked incidents. Additionally, the Tiguan experiences more issues with the power train than the CX-5, but neither model shows crash-linked problems in this category.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize low running costs and reliability, the Mazda CX-5 is an excellent choice. With a high reliability score of 93/100 and an estimated annual repair cost of just $447, it is designed to keep you on the road with minimal hassle. The CX-5's repair frequency is low at 0.3 times per year, and it carries a lower major repair risk of 8%. Despite having 11 recalls, the owner complaints are minimal at 5.6 per 10,000 sold, indicating a generally satisfied ownership experience.

On the other hand, if you are drawn to the Volkswagen Tiguan, be prepared for higher maintenance demands. With a reliability score of 68/100 and an annual repair cost estimate of $730, owning a Tiguan may require more frequent visits to the mechanic, as evidenced by its 0.9 repair frequency per year and a 12% major repair risk. The Tiguan has faced 35 recalls and has a higher rate of owner complaints, which might suggest ongoing issues. Choose the Tiguan if you value its specific features or design, but bear in mind the potential for higher upkeep.

Cost of ownership

Based on independent repair cost data, the Mazda CX-5 is a more cost-effective choice for budget-conscious drivers. With an annual repair cost of $447, it saves approximately $283 each year compared to the $730 required for the Volkswagen Tiguan, amounting to a $1,415 difference over five years. The CX-5 also boasts a lower repair frequency of 0.3 visits per year versus the Tiguan's 0.9 visits, which means fewer disruptions and potential savings on repair-related downtime. Additionally, the Mazda has a lower major repair risk at 8%, compared to the Tiguan's 12%, further solidifying its reputation as a reliable and economical option.