Volvo XC90 vs Lincoln Aviator

Verdict: Volvo XC90 vs Lincoln Aviator

The Volvo XC90 demonstrates superior reliability compared to the Lincoln Aviator, with an average reliability score of 72 versus the Aviator's 64. While both vehicles have common issues with their electrical systems and power trains, the XC90 has a significantly lower owner complaint rate of 4.2 per 10,000 sold compared to the Aviator's 15.7. Despite the XC90's higher estimated annual repair cost of $851 versus the Aviator's $807, its lower recall count of 39 over nine years is a notable advantage against the Aviator's 116 recalls in just six years. Overall, the XC90 offers a more reliable ownership experience, particularly in terms of recall history and owner satisfaction.

Reliability problem analysis

The Volvo XC90 and Lincoln Aviator have similar total complaint numbers, but they show distinct problem profiles. The XC90's most frequent issue is with the electrical system, accounting for 58 complaints, including one crash-linked incident. In contrast, the Aviator also shows a high number of electrical complaints at 54 but with no crash linkage. Notably, the XC90 has more crash-linked issues in its service brakes (3) and visibility/wiper (2) categories compared to the Aviator, which has a higher number of structure-related complaints but fewer crash-linked incidents overall.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize reliability and peace of mind, the Volvo XC90 is the better choice. With a reliability score of 72/100, it surpasses the Lincoln Aviator's score of 64/100. The XC90 has significantly fewer recalls, with 39 compared to the Aviator's 116, and fewer owner complaints per 10,000 sold, at 4.2 versus 15.7. Although its estimated annual repair cost is slightly higher at $851, the lower risk of encountering major issues makes it a more dependable option.

On the other hand, if keeping annual repair costs slightly lower is your main concern, you might lean towards the Lincoln Aviator, which has an estimated annual repair cost of $807. However, be prepared for a higher likelihood of recalls and owner complaints. The Aviator also lacks available data on major repair risk, which could be a concern if long-term reliability is important to you.

Cost of ownership

The Volvo XC90 and Lincoln Aviator show similar repair frequencies, both averaging 0.6 visits per year. However, the Volvo XC90 has a slightly higher annual repair cost of $851 compared to the Lincoln Aviator's $807, translating to a $44 difference annually and an additional $220 over five years. The major repair risk for the XC90 is 11%, while data for the Aviator isn't specified, leaving some uncertainty in long-term reliability. For cost-conscious buyers, the Aviator appears to offer slightly better value due to its lower annual repair cost, though the lack of major repair risk data should be considered.