Hyundai Tucson vs Subaru Forester

Verdict: Hyundai Tucson vs Subaru Forester

The Hyundai Tucson and Subaru Forester both fall within the compact SUV segment, but the Tucson edges out the Forester in reliability, with a higher average reliability score of 83/100 compared to the Forester's 77/100. Although the Tucson has a higher number of recalls (23 versus 13), its owner complaint rate is nearly identical to the Forester's at 8.9 per 10,000 sold. The Tucson also benefits from lower estimated annual repair costs at $426, significantly less than the Forester's $632. The Tucson's common issues include engine and power train problems, whereas the Forester frequently encounters visibility and wiper issues, making the Tucson a slightly more reliable choice overall.

Reliability problem analysis

The Hyundai Tucson and Subaru Forester exhibit distinct problem profiles, with each model facing unique challenges. The Tucson's primary issues are concentrated in the engine and power train categories, with a notable 397 engine complaints and a significant number of crash-linked incidents in the power train (11) and service brakes (15). In contrast, the Forester's most prevalent issue is with visibility/wiper systems, accounting for 819 complaints, while also showing a high number of crash-linked complaints in vehicle speed control (26) and air bags (22). While both models have electrical system concerns, the Forester's visibility-related problems and crash-linked safety issues in airbags stand out, whereas the Tucson is more affected by mechanical reliability concerns.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize low running costs and reliability, the Hyundai Tucson is your best bet. With a higher reliability score of 83/100, it promises fewer headaches and lower annual repair costs at $426. The Tucson also has a lower repair frequency of 0.3 times per year and a slightly lower major repair risk of 10%, making it a sensible choice for those seeking peace of mind and budget-friendly maintenance.

On the other hand, if you are concerned about fewer recalls and slightly lower owner complaints, consider the Subaru Forester. Despite its lower reliability score of 77/100, it has faced fewer recalls, totaling 13, and boasts a comparable owner complaint rate of 8.7 per 10,000 sold. However, be prepared for higher annual repair costs of $632 and a marginally higher major repair risk of 13%. Choose the Forester if these factors align with your priorities.

Cost of ownership

Based on industry estimates, the Hyundai Tucson offers a more economical maintenance experience, with an annual repair cost of $426, compared to the Subaru Forester's $632. Over five years, this equates to a $1,030 savings with the Tucson. Additionally, the Tucson has a lower repair frequency of 0.3 visits per year versus the Forester's 0.4 visits, indicating fewer trips to the mechanic. The major repair risk is also lower for the Tucson at 10%, compared to the Forester's 13%. For cost-conscious buyers, the Hyundai Tucson presents a better value, combining lower costs with reduced repair frequency and risk.