GMC Acadia vs Toyota Highlander

Verdict: GMC Acadia vs Toyota Highlander

The Toyota Highlander edges out the GMC Acadia in terms of reliability, with an average reliability score of 72/100 compared to the Acadia's 69/100. The Highlander also boasts a lower owner complaint rate of 5.8 per 10,000 vehicles sold, contrasting with Acadia's unnormalized 770 total complaints. While the Highlander has a higher total recall number at 66 over nine years, its estimated annual repair costs are significantly lower at $489 versus the Acadia's $734, making it a more cost-effective option for long-term ownership. Both vehicles share common issues, but the Highlander's lower repair costs and complaint rate make it the more reliable choice in the midsize SUV segment.

Reliability problem analysis

The Toyota Highlander exhibits a higher total number of complaints compared to the GMC Acadia, particularly in the areas of power train and air bags, with the latter showing a significant 41 crash-linked incidents. The Highlander also faces notable issues with its service brakes and structure, both registering multiple crash-related complaints. Conversely, the GMC Acadia has a pronounced issue with its power train and electrical system, though it reports fewer overall complaints and crash-linked incidents in the air bags category compared to the Highlander. Both vehicles have a moderate number of complaints related to their engines and fuel/propulsion systems, but these are less frequently linked to crashes.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize reliability and lower running costs, the Toyota Highlander is the better choice. With a reliability score of 72/100, it edges out the GMC Acadia and offers a more economical ownership experience with an estimated annual repair cost of $489. The Highlander's lower repair frequency of 0.3 times per year and a lower major repair risk of 13% make it a dependable option for those who want peace of mind and minimal surprises.

On the other hand, if you are concerned about recalls and prefer a vehicle with fewer historical recalls, consider the GMC Acadia. Despite its slightly lower reliability score of 69/100, the Acadia has only 17 total recalls compared to the Highlander's 66. However, be prepared for higher repair costs at $734 annually and a major repair risk of 19%. If your priority is fewer recalls and you can manage the higher maintenance expenses, the Acadia might be suitable for you.

Cost of ownership

Independent repair cost data suggests that the Toyota Highlander is a more cost-effective option for maintenance and repairs compared to the GMC Acadia. With an annual repair cost of $489, the Highlander is significantly cheaper than the Acadia, which costs $734 annually. Over a period of five years, this results in a savings of $1,225 for Highlander owners.

Additionally, the Highlander has a lower repair frequency, needing service only 0.3 times per year compared to the Acadia's 0.4 visits. Major repair risks are also lower for the Highlander at 13%, while the Acadia carries a 19% risk. For cost-conscious buyers, the Highlander offers better value with its lower repair costs and reduced risk of major repairs.