Ford Explorer vs Toyota Venza

Verdict: Ford Explorer vs Toyota Venza

The Toyota Venza stands out in terms of reliability, boasting a high average reliability score of 91/100 compared to the Ford Explorer's 68/100. With only 5 recalls in four years and an exceptionally low complaint rate of 0.2 per 10,000 units sold, the Venza demonstrates fewer issues than the Explorer, which has 117 recalls over nine years and a complaint rate of 6.8 per 10,000 units. Additionally, the Venza's estimated annual repair cost is significantly lower at $444, compared to the Explorer's $732. Overall, the Venza proves to be the more reliable and cost-effective choice for a midsize SUV.

Reliability problem analysis

The Ford Explorer exhibits a diverse array of issues with a notable concentration in the power train category, accounting for 618 complaints, 12 of which are crash-linked, suggesting potential safety concerns. In contrast, the Toyota Venza has a significantly lower total of 9 complaints, with no crash-linked incidents, primarily involving exterior lighting and fuel/propulsion systems. The Explorer also faces substantial issues in unknown or other categories and structural problems, while the Venza's problem profile is limited and less severe. Overall, the Ford Explorer's broader spectrum of complaints, particularly those linked to crashes, indicates a more complex reliability challenge compared to the Toyota Venza.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize reliability and low running costs, the Toyota Venza is your best choice. With an impressive reliability score of 91/100 and only five total recalls, the Venza stands out for its dependability. You’ll benefit from lower estimated annual repair costs at $444 and a reduced major repair risk of just 10%. Additionally, with only 0.2 owner complaints per 10,000 sold, the Venza provides peace of mind for those seeking a trouble-free ownership experience.

On the other hand, if you’re drawn to the Ford Explorer for its features or design, be aware that it comes with a reliability score of 68/100 and 117 total recalls. The Explorer's annual repair costs are higher at $732, and the major repair risk is 14%. However, it requires fewer repairs per year at 0.2 compared to the Venza’s 0.5. Choose the Explorer if these factors align with your priorities and you're prepared for potential issues with the power train and electrical system.

Cost of ownership

The Ford Explorer incurs an annual repair cost of $732, which is $288 more than the Toyota Venza's $444. This amounts to an additional $1,440 over five years for the Explorer. Additionally, the Explorer has a lower repair frequency at 0.2 visits per year compared to the Venza's 0.5 visits, suggesting fewer trips to the mechanic. However, the Explorer's major repair risk is 14%, higher than the Venza's 10%, indicating a greater chance of costly repairs.

For cost-conscious buyers, the Toyota Venza presents a more economical option. While it may require more frequent visits for minor issues, its lower annual repair cost and reduced major repair risk offer better long-term value.