Toyota Highlander vs Ford Edge

Verdict: Toyota Highlander vs Ford Edge

The Toyota Highlander demonstrates slightly superior reliability with an average score of 72/100 compared to the Ford Edge's 67/100. While the Highlander has a higher number of total recalls at 66 over nine years, its owner complaints per 10,000 sold are notably lower at 5.8, indicating fewer reported issues relative to its sales volume. Additionally, the Highlander's estimated annual repair cost of $489 provides a clearer picture of maintenance expenses, unlike the Edge, which lacks this data. Both vehicles share common issues in powertrain and other areas, but the Highlander's lower complaint rate and defined repair costs give it a slight edge in reliability.

Reliability problem analysis

The Toyota Highlander and Ford Edge exhibit distinct reliability profiles, with both models showing significant issues in different areas. The Highlander has a notable number of complaints related to the power train, accounting for 485 issues, with 5 linked to crashes, and a particularly concerning number of air bag complaints at 162, with 41 crash-linked incidents. In contrast, the Ford Edge's primary concerns lie in the power train as well, with a higher count of 683 complaints, 8 of which are crash-linked, and a significant number of engine-related issues totaling 415 complaints. While the Highlander has more air bag-related safety concerns, the Edge's engine problems are more prevalent, suggesting a divergence in the types of mechanical and safety challenges each vehicle faces.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize reliability and lower repair costs, the Toyota Highlander is the better choice. With a reliability score of 72/100 and an estimated annual repair cost of $489, it offers a more dependable ownership experience. The Highlander reports fewer owner complaints at 5.8 per 10,000 sold, suggesting a more satisfying user experience. Although it has faced 66 recalls, its repair frequency of 0.3 per year and a 13% risk of major repairs are relatively manageable.

For those who value fewer recalls, the Ford Edge may appeal to you. With 32 recalls, it presents fewer recall-related disruptions. However, be mindful of its higher owner complaint rate of 9.4 per 10,000 sold and top issues including powertrain and electrical system concerns. While specific repair costs and frequencies aren't available, the lower reliability score of 67/100 suggests potential for higher maintenance needs. Choose the Edge if fewer recalls are a priority, but prepare for possible ownership challenges.

Cost of ownership

The Toyota Highlander has an annual repair cost of $489, with a repair frequency of 0.3 visits per year and a major repair risk of 13%, according to industry estimates. Although specific figures for the Ford Edge are unavailable, these metrics highlight the Highlander's reliability. With fewer repair visits and a moderate risk for significant repairs, the Highlander presents itself as a cost-effective choice for budget-conscious buyers.

Assuming similar industry standards, if the Ford Edge were to have higher repair frequency or major repair risk, the Highlander would likely save owners money in the long run. Over five years, the Highlander’s consistent performance could translate to greater savings and peace of mind.