Toyota Highlander vs Buick Enclave

Verdict: Toyota Highlander vs Buick Enclave

The Buick Enclave edges out the Toyota Highlander in reliability with a higher average reliability score of 75/100 compared to the Highlander's 72/100. The Enclave also benefits from a significantly lower recall count, with just 10 recalls over nine years versus the Highlander's 66. Additionally, the Enclave has fewer owner complaints, with a rate of 2.6 per 10,000 sold compared to the Highlander's 5.8. Although repair cost estimates are unavailable for the Enclave, its lower complaint and recall rates suggest a more reliable ownership experience.

Reliability problem analysis

The Toyota Highlander exhibits a higher volume of complaints, particularly in the power train and air bags categories, with 485 and 162 complaints respectively, the latter being notably severe with 41 crash-linked incidents. In contrast, the Buick Enclave has a significantly lower total number of complaints, with its most reported issues being in the electrical system and power train, tallying 39 and 35 complaints respectively. While both vehicles experience problems with service brakes and power train, the Highlander's air bag issues stand out due to their higher crash linkage. The Highlander's broader range of issues across multiple components suggests a more diverse problem profile compared to the more concentrated and less severe complaint distribution in the Enclave.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize a reliable driving experience with fewer recalls, the Buick Enclave, with a reliability score of 75/100 and only 10 total recalls, might be the better choice. Its lower owner complaints rate of 2.6 per 10,000 sold suggests a smoother ownership experience, especially if you are concerned about frequent service visits. However, be aware that detailed repair cost and frequency data are missing, which could be important for long-term budgeting.

On the other hand, if keeping repair costs predictable is your priority, the Toyota Highlander offers an estimated annual repair cost of $489 and a repair frequency of 0.3 per year. Despite having a slightly lower reliability score of 72/100 and more recalls, its maintenance expenses are straightforward, making it suitable for budget-conscious buyers. Consider the Highlander if you value transparency in potential repair expenses.

Cost of ownership

Independent repair cost data indicates that the Toyota Highlander incurs an average annual repair cost of $489, with a repair frequency of 0.3 visits per year and a 13% risk of major repairs. In contrast, specific data for the Buick Enclave's repair costs and frequency are not available, making a direct financial comparison challenging. However, industry insights suggest that the Highlander's lower repair frequency and moderate risk of major repairs position it as a more predictable choice for cost-conscious buyers over time. Assuming similar repair costs, the Highlander’s reliability could potentially offer better long-term value, particularly if major repairs are less frequent.