Honda CR-V vs Hyundai Tucson

Verdict: Honda CR-V vs Hyundai Tucson

The Honda CR-V and Hyundai Tucson both fall within the compact SUV segment, with the CR-V holding a slight edge in reliability. The CR-V boasts an average reliability score of 89/100 compared to the Tucson’s 83/100, and it also benefits from a lower estimated annual repair cost of $407 versus the Tucson’s $426. Both models have a similar rate of owner complaints per 10,000 vehicles sold, but the CR-V's higher number of recalls, at 46 over nine years, may be a point of concern. Overall, the CR-V's higher reliability score and lower repair costs make it a marginally more dependable choice, despite its recall history.

Reliability problem analysis

The Honda CR-V exhibits a higher volume of complaints, with notable issues in steering and forward collision avoidance, both of which are linked to crashes with 24 and 13 incidents, respectively. In contrast, the Hyundai Tucson's most significant problem area is the engine, with 397 complaints, mirroring the CR-V in crash-linked engine complaints but with a greater proportion overall. Both models show vulnerabilities in their electrical systems and service brakes, yet the CR-V's steering problems are a distinct concern not mirrored in the Tucson. The Tucson, however, has a higher proportion of crash-linked complaints in its power train and vehicle speed control categories, highlighting potential safety concerns in these areas.

Which one to buy

If you prioritize reliability and are willing to overlook a higher number of recalls, the Honda CR-V is a strong contender with a reliability score of 89/100. It offers a slightly lower estimated annual repair cost of $407 and a lower major repair risk of 9%. While it has faced more recalls, with a total of 46, it maintains a lower owner complaint rate of 8 per 10,000 sold, making it a solid choice for those who value dependable performance over the long term.

On the other hand, if you are more concerned about the number of recalls and can tolerate a slightly higher repair cost, the Hyundai Tucson could be suitable for you. With fewer recalls at 23, the Tucson presents fewer potential interruptions in ownership. Though it has a marginally higher reliability score of 83/100 and slightly higher annual repair cost of $426, it remains a viable option for those who prioritize a balanced approach to cost and reliability.

Cost of ownership

According to industry estimates, the Honda CR-V has an annual repair cost of $407, slightly cheaper than the Hyundai Tucson's $426. This $19 difference per year sums up to $95 over five years. Both vehicles have the same repair frequency of 0.3 visits annually, indicating similar maintenance demands. However, the CR-V has a lower major repair risk at 9%, compared to the Tucson's 10%. For cost-conscious buyers, the Honda CR-V offers slightly better value with its lower annual repair cost and reduced likelihood of major repairs, making it a more economical choice in the long run.